To Die For

Parshas Emor

To Die For

By Rabbi Dovid Zauderer


In this week’s Torah portion, Parshas Emor, we find the mitzvah of Kiddush Hashem, sanctifying G-d’s name. As it is written, “… I shall be sanctified among the Children of Israel…” (Leviticus 22:32). This commandment specifically requires one to be martyred rather than publicly transgress any religious law where religious persecution is intended.

As you know, throughout the centuries and millennia, our holy ancestors have sanctified G-d’s Name countless times, and through their deaths they made the ultimate statement of faith – that the Torah is G-d’s absolute truth and is even worth dying for (that said, it should never happen to any of us, Heaven forbid!)

What you may not know is that, according to most Halachic authorities, one who is being put to death in sanctification of G-d’s Name in the presence of at least ten Jews, is obligated to make a blessing – “Blessed are You … Who has sanctified us with His commandments and instructed us to publicly sanctify His Name” - before fulfilling the commandment.

The Rishonim (medieval commentaries) ask why it is that we make blessings before performing most mitzvos, yet we find many other mitzvos upon which the Rabbis did not institute a blessing, e.g., the commandment to give tzedakah (charity) to a poor person.

One answer given by the Avudraham is that the Rabbis did not ordain a blessing on a mitzvah that depends on another person for its fulfillment, such as giving tzedakah, since the recipient may be unwilling to be helped and the whole mitzvah will then have become nullified.

Based on this reasoning of the Avudraham, the Shelah HaKadosh (in Shaar HaOsiyos - Os Alef) asks why one should then make a blessing before being put to death in sanctification of G-d’s Name, since this mitzvah’s fulfillment is also dependent on another person – the fellow who is about to kill him!

The Shelah HaKadosh answers that the mitzvah of Kiddush Hashem is not a commandment to actually die for G-d Torah – to the point that, if the guy changes his mind at the last minute and doesn’t kill the Jew, he hasn’t fulfilled the commandment. Rather, it is the statement that one makes by being ready to die for G-d’s Torah that is the essence of the mitzvah – and that is fulfilled whether he ends up getting killed or not.

In fact, the Rabbis teach us that when a Jew reads the first paragraph of the Shema each day where it says “And you shall love the Lord, your G-d … with your whole life” (Deuteronomy 6:5), and he includes the intent that he is ready to give up his life to sanctify God's name, it is considered in heaven as if he had actually done so.

The Rashb”a (in his Responsa 5:55) phrased it as follows: "King David wrote in Psalms (44:23): 'We were killed for You [G-d] every day'. Is it possible to be killed every day? When we read in the Shema, ‘with your whole life', and we undertake to fulfill those words, it is as if we are being killed at that moment for G-d, may He be blessed. When a Jew undertakes to perform a mitzvah when the opportunity will arise, it is considered as if he did it.”

All through our history, our great ancestors were able to die for G-d and His Torah because they knew what it meant to live for G-d and His Torah.

Now, thank G-d, we live in a relatively tranquil period of history for the Jewish people, when the likelihood of any Jew having to die for his religion is practically nil.

But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t have anything to die for. Because if we have nothing to die for, then we have nothing to live for.

[Ed. Note: Just two important points to share with you about martyrs and martyrdom:

(1) One who is killed because he is Jewish, even though he is not given any choice, is still considered a martyr (such as in the Holocaust). Even an evildoer who goes to his death as a Jew sanctifies G-d and is considered holy.

(2) The Arvei Nachal in Parshas Masei quotes the Mahara”m Mi”Rotenberg (c.1220-1293) who has a tradition handed down man-to-man straight from Mount Sinai that any Jew who goes to his death with full love and awe of G-d will feel absolutely no pain, as no delight in life is as great and as perfect as that of a martyr.-dz]

GOOD SHABBOS!

http://www.torchweb.org/torah_detail.php?id=755

Back to Archives